subsciption
features new products gun links departments web blast store
searchservicecontactssafetyhome                            
  GUNS 2010 ANNUAL   GUNS 2010 ANNUAL
     
Share |
     
Reproduced from the February 2009 issue of GUNS Magazine.
     
Match Master
Springfield Armory's XD (M) Just Might Be A
Success In Police And Military Markets, Too.
     
Story By Dave Anderson
Photos By Chuck Pittman
     
         
The XD pistol, a big success for Springfield Armory, is an extremely well designed and well-made pistol, reliable and durable. It is a recoil-operated, locked breech, tilting barrel semiautomatic. Lockup is similar in function to (among others) Glock and Sig designs, with an abutment on the barrel ahead of the chamber locking into the front edge of the ejection port. An angled track on a lug beneath the barrel controls locking and unlocking. This design has been well proven to be strong, simple and reliable.
     
The fire control mechanism is similar to that of the popular Glock pistols. It is neither single nor double action. There is no hammer; instead, there is a spring-loaded striker, the spring compressed when the slide has been racked to chamber a cartridge. Pressing the trigger releases the striker to fire the cartridge.

The new XD(M) is an interesting variation of the excellent XD pistol. What I find especially interesting is what the XD(M) features suggest about Springfield Armory’s marketing plans for the pistol. This is just personal speculation, mind you. Springfield hasn’t invited me to any of its staff meetings, but I’m guessing Springfield wants to take a serious run at the large-scale police and military market.

I get the impression Springfield showed the XD to various police and military units (or maybe just discussed it among themselves) and said, “We have a good pistol here. What changes are needed in order to make it the ideal service pistol?”

Consider the biggest differences between the XD and the XD(M): Magazines: standard XD magazines are strongly made of stainless steel for heavy-duty use. XD(M) magazines seem to be built even more heavily, and hold more cartridges (16 in .40 S&W caliber compared to 13 for the standard XD). As far as I know this is the highest capacity of any polymer-framed .40 S&W pistol. There are numbered witness holes for rounds four through 16. Magazines between the two models are not interchangeable.

Interchangeable grip backstraps: the XD(M) comes with three sizes of backstrap inserts you can readily interchange. This feature is becoming increasingly popular with police agencies and military units. It lets the agency issue one pistol design (with consequent savings in armorer training, spare parts and magazines inventory, holsters/magazine carriers, and basic firearm training) while still enabling officers to have a pistol fit to their hand.

This is especially interesting: As part of the takedown process, the standard XD (as with other striker-fired designs) requires the striker spring to be released by pulling the trigger on an empty chamber. Basic firearms safety rules require the muzzle be pointed in a safe direction with a secure backstop any time the pistol is dry fired.

Those who have disassembled an XD are probably wondering why this would be an issue. The takedown procedure makes it virtually impossible for a live round to remain in the chamber during the process, without the shooter’s knowledge.

The XD slide must be locked to the rear in order to rotate the takedown lever. Retracting the slide back of course ejects any round which might be in the chamber. The shooter would have to deliberately load a cartridge back in the chamber before closing the slide and pressing the trigger to release the striker spring. As far as safety goes I consider this a non-issue. The process is safe unless the shooter deliberately sets out to circumvent it, which no design can prevent.

Whether you or I consider this an issue is beside the point. What does matter is some purchasing agencies do consider it an issue. I know of at least one major police agency which, in its evaluation process to select a new duty pistol, specifically included a requirement disassembly not require the trigger be pulled on an empty chamber.

We could point out the XD disassembly process I’ve outlined. We can argue — correctly —the process is completely safe unless the shooter deliberately sets out to make it unsafe, which can happen with any design. We can point out similar processes have been safely used for decades with millions of guns. We can argue until we’re blue in the face, but if a bureaucracy lists a requirement, it can be darn hard to convince it to change.

The designers of the XD(M) evidently decided to simply take the issue off the table. Although the takedown process of the XD(M) is otherwise identical to that of the XD, There is no need to press the trigger and release the striker spring. Simply lock the slide back, rotate the takedown lever to point up, then release the slide lock and run the slide/barrel assembly forward off the frame. Lift out the recoil spring/guide rod assembly, remove the barrel through the bottom/rear of the slide and you’ve gone as far as necessary for routine cleaning and maintenance.

In common with the XD, the XD(M) is about as well designed against unintentional discharge as a pistol can be. Start with the little tab in the trigger face. The purpose of this tab is not to act as a manual safety, since it is released by the normal action of pressing the trigger. Rather, its purpose is to keep the pistol from firing due to trigger inertia if it is dropped.

The concern was if the pistol was dropped from a great height and landed on a hard surface at just the right (or wrong?) angle, the weight of the trigger might cause it to move enough to fire the gun. The trigger tab locks it against such movement and ensures it can only move back when deliberately pulled.
The slide has a positive locking block to prevent the striker from moving forward, until the block is cleared by the final compression of the trigger. The XD/XD(M) pistols also have a grip safety which must be depressed to allow trigger function. In short, if the shooter grips the pistol correctly and presses the trigger the gun will fire. Otherwise it won’t.

Two other features help the shooter monitor the status of their pistol. When the striker is in its compressed mode, a small pin extends from the rear face of the slide. When a cartridge is chambered the extractor extends above the top surface of the slide. At a touch or glance the shooter can quickly check these two features. They don’t take away the requirement to visually check and confirm the pistol is unloaded before cleaning or storage. They do give the option of quickly and unobtrusively confirming the pistol’s status, even in low-light conditions, which can be a great comfort.

The XD(M) incorporates about every possible feature to ensure the pistol will only fire when the shooter deliberately chooses to make it fire. For all its multiplicity of safety-related features the XD(M) is a simple pistol to operate. The same simplicity of operation kept the revolver in police holsters for decades. There are no levers or switches to operate while under the enormous stress of facing a deadly threat. Loaded and with a cartridge chambered the XD(M) is as simple to operate — just point gun, pull trigger.

Turning to ergonomics, the grip angle of XD pistols feels just right to this long-term 1911 user. The interchangeable backstrap of the XD(M) is a worthwhile feature. My hands are a bit bigger than average and I get along just fine with the standard XD or the intermediate backstrap insert of the XD(M).

A police officer friend with large hands finds these a bit small, but is well suited with the largest of the three inserts provided. Swapping inserts is easy and fast, provided you have the right size punch to tap out the roll pin securing the insert.

The ambidextrous magazine release button could hardly be improved. It is located at the “1911” position, at the base of the triggerguard. It is protected against accidental release by a dished area molded in the grip, but is easily activated by either the thumb or trigger finger.
At the front of the frame is another worthwhile improvement. The standard XD accessory rail has one cross slot. The XD(M) has three slots, to permit more flexibility in positioning accessories such as white or infrared lights or laser aiming devices.

The grip frame is molded in a striking and unusual pattern to enhance the shooter’s grasp on the gun. The photographs show it better than I can describe it. I can say it works very well, keeping the gun from shifting in the hand while shooting, without causing discomfort in long shooting sessions. It works fine and looks neat. The bottom of the mag well is relieved to help ensure fast, consistent reloads.
     
The XD has a convenient ambidextrous magazine release in the same position
as the 1911, the place most looked for by American shooters.
     
The XD(M) comes with a very useful holster as part of the package.
     
Finishes

XD(M) slides are available in satin stainless steel for shooters who prefer the two-tone look, or with a low-luster, rust-resistant finish which Springfield calls Melonite. I rather like the two-tone look but this is simply a matter of personal preference. Both styles are tough and attractive.

The shape of the slide differs a bit from the standard XD, tapering towards the top. I couldn’t find any advantage one way or the other during routine handling, loading and unloading. The design works and it looks good; I can’t ask for more than that. The sights are strongly mounted in the slide in dovetail grooves and provide an excellent sight picture.

Trigger pull on the test gun was what I consider on the heavy side at 7-1/2 pounds, but smooth and consistent. One reason the standard XD has done well in competition is its excellent trigger, which can be readily tuned to pulls less than four pounds. This is fine for competition, but most experts would consider it too light for a duty pistol, especially one intended for general issue to users who may not be particularly interested in shooting.

At this time I don’t know if the redesigned XD(M) trigger will be as amenable to tuning to a light pull as the standard XD. Admittedly this is only a concern to competition shooters. For defensive use the XD(M) trigger is just fine as it is.

Even though it is heavier than I am used to I found the XD(M) trigger easy to shoot. It is consistent and smooth, and has a short, very fast reset. What this means is after the shot breaks the trigger finger has to move forward only a short distance to let the trigger reset. Takeup for the next shot is likewise short.

Everything about this pistol indicates high quality materials and workmanship. Machining of the steel slide is crisp, straight and smooth. Molding of the polymer frame is likewise crisp and even. Barrel fit and slide/frame fit are excellent, with little discernible play. All operating components fit and functioned as they should.

Functioning proved 100-percent reliable. I fired over 500 rounds through the pistol, most of it Black Hills 180-grain JHP and 155-grain JHP loads, both for accuracy testing and in fast shooting at steel and paper targets. At 25 yards, 5-shot groups were consistently less than 3", with the majority of groups around 2-1/2".

The XD(M) comes in a well-made hard case along with two magazines, a good quality synthetic holster and double magazine carrier, two additional backstrap inserts and a magazine loading tool. The loading tool is very handy for getting the last two or three rounds in the magazines. I could manage without it, but when doing a lot of shooting, the loading tool does make the process easier.

The XD(M) has the features, reliability and quality to appeal to demanding police and military purchasers. Whether Springfield decides to aggressively pursue this market remains to be seen. It’s a tough and highly competitive market. There’s a lot more involved than just selling a bunch of pistols. These buyers also want ongoing service such as spare parts and magazines, armorer training, firearms instructor training.

Regardless, private citizens (including police officers who can purchase and carry their own duty sidearm) have an excellent choice for a personal and home defense pistol in the Springfield XD(M).
     
     
 
The slide is nicely sculpted with fore-and-aft grasping serrations (left), while the bottom accessory rail has extra slots to aid in positioning lights or lasers. As with many of like kind, the XD(M) has a trigger (right) with a safety tab to prevent the trigger from moving if the pistol is dropped. Note the protected magazine release. The takedown lever (just under the slide) is sculpted and snag free.
     
As with the original XD, the new XD(M) also has a cocking indicator which
protrudes from the back of the slide when the striker is cocked.
     
   
 
XD(M)
Maker: HS Produkt d.o.o.
M. Bogovica 7, 47000 Karlovac, Croatia
Importer: Springfield Armory
420 West Main Street, Geneseo, IL 61254
(309) 944-5631
www.springfield-armory.com
       
 
Action type:
 
Locked breech, semi-automatic
 
Caliber:
  .40 S&W (tested), 9mm Luger
 
Frame:
  Polymer
 
Slide:
  Steel or stainless steel
 
Barrel length:
  4.5"
 
Overall length
  7.5"
 
Weight:
  32 ounces
 
Capacity:
  16 (.40 S&W), 19 (9mm Luger)
 
Retail::
  $679 (black), $749 (2-tone)
       
 
       
  Order Your Copy
Of The February
Issue Today!
 
 
     
       

This column is sponsored by:

Kimber
www.kimberamerica.com

Crimson Trace
www.crimsontrace.com
 
       
   
       
             
    Features | Departments | Gun Links | New Products | Subscribe | WebBlast | Digital Editions
Store | Customer Service | Contact Us | Search | Safety | Advertising | Site Map | Home